The Education Board>
Can market forces fix education?
TheMudge
The Real Mudge
2654 post s
19-Apr-2008
9:48 PM
A friend and I have been exchanging e-mails about the failure of public education. My friend is an optimist. He concedes that the schools have slipped badly, but he believes that "market forces" will eventually correct the situation (he's a great believer in the power of the market). He writes: "When management can no longer rely on ANYONE/ANYWHERE to clean up their acts, SOMEONE will scream bloody murder . . . ."

After pointing out that the situation has been going on for so long that companies must by now be feeling the impact of a poorly educated workforce, I asked, "What's taking them so long?"

My question is threefold:
1. Can market forces address failures in education?
2. Will they?
3. What exactly can they do?
----------
Rich Turner (The Curmudgeon Himself)

Pogo

334 post s
21-Apr-2008
8:32 AM
There are those who ascribe the beginning of the mess to corporations, who wanted unthinking drones in the workforce late in the 19th century.

Employers are aware of the problems. Parents are too. Even governments are. Unfortunately, teachers' unions want to maintain their control so they can have all that dues money. In most school systems, teachers do not have to know the subject they teach, but they must have been taught how to teach (hah!). They must not deviate from the approved methods. School boards decide what subjects must be taught, or offered, but often do not make clear a line of progression through the subject over the years. It's going to have to be parents who finally succeed, and that's going to parents who have the will and the time. In other words: the rich. We can but hope that the fix spreads throughout the school system.

Note: my father's father was an organizer for John Mitchell and John L. Lewis; my mother was a stenographer for years at the HQ of the International Typographical Union. Unions had a place...